bad news is that they want to make Marvel’s supernatural comic book hero
Doctor Strange into a big-budget live action movie. The good news is that
it will be directed by Guillermo Del Toro and based on a screenplay by
Neil Gaiman . . .
Created by comic book legend Stan Lee and artist Steve
Ditko as far back as 1963, the good doctor has never been one of our
favorite Marvel characters to be honest, so we’re not particularly excited
about a big screen movie.
To recap: Dr. Stephen Vincent Strange is, um, Doctor
Strange. A renowned but arrogant surgeon, Strange has an automobile
accident one day and suffers some damage to his hands. Being unable to
practice as a medical doctor anymore turns out to be a lesson in humility
for Strange even though he still later on refers to himself as the
“Sorcerer Supreme”. Not only that, but seeking a cure he comes across an
ancient wise man called the, um, Ancient One in the Himalayas (where
else?) who teaches the good doctor some, like, real magic.
Strange returns to the States as a nattily dressed
magician with real supernatural powers where he combats evil, usually in
the guise of supernatural threats such as ethereal demons and not just
pickpockets or the sort of criminal that everyday people like you and me
must unfortunately cope with.
The problem with the Dr. Strange comics has
always been his humourless persona. Strange is at his best as a bit
character in someone else’s title, the straight guy against whom the hero
bounces quips off – the expert Spider-man consults when he is up against a
supernatural threat and out of his depth. Making Dr. Strange the hero of
his own comic is like making the Jedi the heroes of the
Star Wars movies . . . and we all know
how that turned out! Put simply: Dr. Strange and his otherworldly concerns
is simply too far removed from everyday human issues to identify with.
Making him the hero of a movie would be like making The Karate Kid,
but with Mr. Miyagi as the hero instead of Ralph Macchio . . .
"It's like The Karate Kid, but with Mr. Miyagi as the hero
instead of Ralph Macchio . . ."
Dr. Strange was popular with college types back
in the ‘Sixties thanks to Ditko’s surrealistic art work (the comic you can
get stoned to!). That Marvel is willing to making a big budget movie based
on such a lesser-known character is largely thanks to the recent good box
office of Iron Man – not exactly an A-lister
himself unlike let’s say Spider-man or
the Fantastic Four.
Getting Guillermo Del Toro who directed the
Hellboy movies and the much celebrated
Pan’s Labyrinth to direct
it is sheer genius. So is getting Neil Gaiman (Stardust,
the Sandman comics) to do the screenplay. If there are any two
people who can make one actually look forward to a Dr. Strange
movie adaptation, it’d be these two.
Marvel must have been sorely tempted though to simply
get a hack like Mummy /
Van Helsing director Stephen Sommers
instead of waiting for a space in Del Toro’s busy schedule! (Del Toro is
going to direct the two movies based on Tolkien’s
The Hobbit next.) That is especially if the recent full-length
Doctor Strange (2007) animated movie is anything to go by.
Tasked with introducing the character to new audiences,
it is an “origin” story in which the Doctor is reinvented as . . . a hip
anime character. Who knows, like, martial arts. And magic. And stuff. OK,
we’re being unfair, the movie isn’t that bad, but it is likely to irk
long-time fans of the comic. But the movie goes someway towards humanizing
Strange. It is after all tough to have an unlikable arrogant asshole as
your hero, even if he does eventually find Zen peace and protects our
Earthly plane against other-dimensional demons . . .
But the action in this animated movie tends to be on the
superficial spectacle-driven side, a case of “it looks cool, but what
exactly is happening?”
With all the advances in special effects over the
past decade one can easily imagine a director such as Sommers or (God
forbid!) Rob Cohen OD’ing on a noisy, over-the-top CGI extravaganza.
Hopefully Del Toro however doesn’t seem all that interested in
re-inventing the character for a young hip audience.
“I talked with Neil Gaiman [about writing it],” he said in an interview. “I said, that's an
interesting character because you can definitely make him more in the
pulpy occult detective/magician mold and formula than was done in the
Weird Tales, for example. The idea of a character that really dabbles in
the occult in a way that's not X-Filey, where the supernatural is taken
for granted. That's interesting.”
That’s the good news. The bad news is that if you’re a
long-time fan you’d be disappointed to hear that Del Toro is going to
ditch Doctor Strange’s famous – or is that infamous? – suit, one of the
more flamboyantly camp outfits in a comic book universe not particularly
renowned for its sartorial restraint. But hey, you can’t win them all . .