STARRING: Bruce Willis, Joseph Gordon-Levitt,
Emily Blunt, Paul Dano, Noah Segan, Piper Perabo, Jeff Daniels
2012, 118 Minutes, Directed by:
odd thing about Joseph Gordon-Levitt and Bruce Willis both being in
Looper is not that they both play
the same character but that they’ve both made much better films just like this.
Gordon-Levitt was in the equally complex Inception
and Willis was in the twisted time travel story 12 Monkeys.
Here writer/director Rian
Johnson takes an interesting premise – a man tasked with murdering his future
self – and adds so many extraneous complications that he loses his way. Viewers
are likely to be intrigued, but not completely satisfied.
Joe (Gordon-Levitt) lives in
the year 2042 but works for gangsters from the year 2072. See, time travel has
been invented but instantly outlawed, so apparently the only working device is
held by a criminal boss who uses it to eliminate people. A person marked for
death is sent back, bound and masked, to 2042 where Joe or one of his
counterparts kills him and disposes of the body. No fuss, no muss. Of course the
killers are an untied loose end and so they know one day they will have to close
the loop by executing their future selves. They can then enjoy a well paid
thirty year retirement until time is up.
If that sounds a bit contrived
– are there really no other time machines, not even in later centuries? – at
least it sets up the premise where Old Joe (Willis) shows up and Joe hesitates,
giving his future self the chance to escape. The confrontation between past and
future selves, each with different agendas, is intriguing.
"A muddled echo of several other films where the filmmakers treated
their ideas as something more than a gimmick . . ."
Johnson, though, might have
brought in a science fiction writer with some familiarity with the paradoxes of
time travel stories. We see that the 2072 characters can be altered by changes
to their 2042 selves, but since they’re from the future wouldn’t those changes
have already taken place? At one point old Joe complains that a discussion about
time travel will turn into making diagrams with straws and he wants no part of
it. Neither, apparently, did Johnson, because he ignores most of the issues he
Abe (Jeff Daniels in a nice
turn) is the local crime boss who has come from the future and lives in 2042
under tight security. Why? What’s in it for him? Isn’t he imprisoned in the past
unable to enjoy his ill-gotten gains? Then there’s the out of left field plot
point that some people have mutated to have telekinetic abilities, able to move
things with their minds. It’s raised and then disappears for long stretches of
the story only to prove crucial late in the film. It feels like Johnson painted
himself into a corner with his time travel story and retrofitted it with this
additional gimmick to get himself out.
Indeed the film slows down to a
crawl midway through as Joe, Old Joe, and Abe are all chasing each other,
hiding, or looking for a child who is destined to become “the Rainmaker”, who is
single-handedly taking over the 2072 crime syndicate. Since Joe is hiding out on
a farm run Sara (Emily Blunt), who is taking care of her orphaned nephew, it’s
not too hard to see where all this is heading, especially if you’ve see the
Terminator movies. The payoff
is something that turns out to be clever but little more than that, lacking the
emotional punch that was clearly intended.
With a talented cast and an
unusual premise Looper had the opportunity to be the science fiction
movie of the year. Instead, it’s a muddled echo of several other films where the
filmmakers treated their ideas as something more than a gimmick . . .
Daniel M. Kimmel is a
veteran movie critic and author of a host of film-related books. His first
novel, Shh! It’s a Secret: a novel about Aliens, Hollywood and the Bartender’s
Guide will be released in January. He teaches film at Suffolk University and
lives in Somerville, Massachusetts.