Richard Matheson’s classic novel gets based on combining a couple of basic ideas that we are all familiar with (a) that sometimes the cure is worse than the disease, and (b) how we react in a time of change that seems to threaten our way of life. These basic concepts are at the heart of this seminal work that gave rise to a whole new sub-genre of science fiction—one based on biological elements that affect our species in fundamental ways.

I Am Legend is a 1954 post-apocalyptic, science fiction/horror novel by American writer Richard Matheson that was influential in the modern development of zombie and vampire literature and in popularizing the concept of a worldwide apocalypse due to disease. The novel was a success and got adapted into three films, all of which have different interpretations of the source material, especially regarding the victims of the pandemic that changes the world. The novel also gets credit as the inspiration behind Night of the Living Dead (1968).

These three adaptations all juggle different elements of the original story in different ways. Because of when they got made, they have different sensibilities and approaches that reflect the period of their creation. In chronological order, are, The Last Man on Earth (1964) featuring Vincent Price and made in Italy, this is a more melodramatic interpretation, which has achieved the status of a cult classic. The Omega Man (1971), featuring Charlton Heston in another classic cult interpretation, is a not-too-subtle paranoid warning which emphasizes the threat of social change the victims of the disease represent. In this version of the story, they get portrayed as a cult of murderous anti-science hippies determined to wipe out any vestiges of the past that created them.

The third film. titled the same as the novel that inspired it, is I Am Legend (2007)  featuring Will Smith in a memorable, nuanced tour de force portrayal of the novel’s main protagonist Robert Neville. This most recent version is the first big-budget attempt to bring the classic story to the big screen and is easily the most cinematic of the three. I Am Legend, although flawed, due to bad choices regarding the use of CGI and a narrative that begins to unravel towards the end, emerges as the most palatable version, partially due to its more recent vintage, and more modern sensibilities. This film also features one of the best performances on screen by a dog in recent memory.

Directed by Francis Lawrence, the film stars Will Smith as US Army virologist Robert Neville. The story, this time, is set in New York City after a virus, created to cure cancer, has wiped out most of humanity, leaving Neville as the last human in New York, other than nocturnal mutants. Neville is immune to the virus, and he works to develop a cure while defending himself against the hostile creatures in the vicinity.

Part of the controversy surrounding this film revolves around the movie’s ending, of which there are two the original ending and a director’s ending that are radically different. In the original version, Neville finds a cure but ends up sacrificing himself to so it can get shared with a colony of survivors outside the city. In the ‘directors’ cut, the story gets resolved more peacefully, and Neville survives to share the cure himself with other survivors outside the city. I am not sure if there is an ending I prefer, the one in which Neville dies is way more dramatic. But the alternative is way more hopeful, and hopeful is always a good thing.

 

Our Score
C

By Craig Suide

A genuine (OCD) enthusiast of Sci-FI and fantasy. Addicted to stories. a life-long fan of movies, TV, and pop culture in general. Purchased first comic book at age five, and never stopped. Began reading a lot early on, and discovered ancient mythology, and began reading science fiction around the same time. Made first attempts at writing genre fiction around age 12 Freelance writer for Sci-Fi Nerd (Facebook), retired professional gourmet chef. ex-musician, and illustrator

One thought on “I Am Legend (2007): A Flawed Modern Classic – Which Ending Do You Prefer?”
  1. A recurring theme in virtually all of the apocalyptic movies derived from this “I Am legend” novel, is that the vampire/zombie/psycho/werewolf/whatever! germ that converts people into dangerous monsters, is spread SIMULTANEOUSLY all over the entire world at once. If there actually was, say, a zombie infection disease, it would NOT do that, but would be isolated in the ‘cluster effect’, spread quickly in small geographic areas and burn out abruptly, like the Eboli Virus in Africa actually did. If you got a SUDDEN and GLOBAL contagion through all of the Earth’s population, then, that is an ARRANGED attack by someone, like a space alien trying to wipe out the human species, without damaging the buildings or devices, like a super-selective Neutron bomb that will not destroy the world’s environment or poison it, so that his race could move in lock stock and barrel. That being said, I find it very hard to believe that this current ‘Coronapochalyse’ disease, the
    COVID-19 virus, was not created by advanced genetic engineering in a lab somewhere, it’s simply so pervasive that it seems unnatural!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.